Circuit fingerprinting from a guard-relay position achieves ≥99.9% accuracy with FPR ≤0.1% for all four Tor circuit types (general, HSDir, introductory, rendezvous) using the Deep Fingerprinting classifier on the first 512 cells, despite Tor's deployed partial defenses. Onion-Location fingerprinting (OLF) combining these circuit classifiers then achieves 98.81–99.87% accuracy (FPR 0.16–1.23%) distinguishing O-L sessions from ordinary clearnet or onion-only visits.

Scanning 0.91B unique SANs extracted from 3.7B certificates across 17 CT logs revealed 3,330 unique .onion addresses configured by 26,937 domains. After six months, only 2,101 onions (63%) remained reachable, of which 1,505 (72%) had matching clearnet index pages, constituting the effectively enumerable target set for a targeted OLF adversary.

§4.1 evaluation

Local onion association—periodically downloading the full set of onion associations from a CT-log-based API and performing each lookup locally—produces a traffic pattern from the guard's perspective that is indistinguishable from generic onion service access, eliminating both the OLF fingerprint and the DNS-based Website Oracle attack vector. This approach requires no per-connection clearnet exit circuit and imposes negligible overhead given the current ~1,500 stable O-L site count.

§2.2.4, §6 defense

OLF reduces an adversary's target anonymity set from roughly 10,000 active onionsites to the ~1,500 stably available O-L sites—nearly an order of magnitude. Because O-L requires an exit circuit with a DNS lookup, a DNS-based Website Oracle further collapses the false-positive rate, making OLF effectively a closed-world attack on the enumerated O-L site list.

§2.3, §3 detection

Automatic Onion-Location redirect was disabled in Tor Browser 13.0.12 as a direct result of this research, because automatic redirect forces the distinguishable clearnet-then-onion circuit pattern on every visit without user awareness. Manual O-L remains in Tor Browser but is still fingerprintable with the same near-perfect accuracy since the exit→onion circuit sequence is identical whether the redirect is automatic or manually triggered.

§2.2, footnote 1; §6 evaluation

With infinite training time, Laserbeak achieves 93.5%, 95.9%, and 95.9% accuracy against ephemeral padding, FRONT, and Interspace respectively, compared to 96.5% undefended — confirming that padding-only defenses provide no meaningful protection against a sufficiently trained deep-learning WF adversary. Only ephemeral blocking defenses retain measurable protection, reducing Laserbeak to 71.8% accuracy under infinite training versus 96.5% undefended.

2026-pulls-ephemeral-network-layer-fingerprinting §5.3, Table 2 ml-classifierwebsite-fingerprinttraffic-shape

A plug-and-play Boundary Preserving Aggregation Module (overlapping window partitioning with joint packet- and burst-level features, W=20ms, stride=10ms) consistently improves existing WF baselines without architectural modification: applied to DF, AUC rises from 0.780 to 0.901 and P@5 from 0.315 to 0.545; applied to ARES'25, P@5 rises from 0.869 to 0.900 in the open-world 5-tab setting. The module's consistent gains across all three tested baselines confirm that fixed non-overlapping window segmentation is a structural vulnerability in prior WF pipelines.

2026-yuan-demux-boundary-aware-multi-scale §V-G, Figure 5 website-fingerprintml-classifiertraffic-shape

DEMUX achieves a P@5 of 0.943 and MAP@5 of 0.961 in the closed-world 5-tab multi-tab website fingerprinting setting, outperforming the strongest prior baseline (ARES'25) by 9.2 and 6.2 percentage points respectively. ARES'25's P@K degrades from 0.900 at 2-tab to 0.851 at 5-tab (a drop of 4.9 pp), while DEMUX improves from 0.926 to 0.943 over the same range, expanding the absolute margin from 2.6 to over 9 points.

2026-yuan-demux-boundary-aware-multi-scale §V-B, Table II website-fingerprintml-classifiertraffic-shape

Censorship classifiers and traffic analysis attacks consistently exploit the initial seconds of a proxy connection, where packet-size, inter-arrival-time, and burst features are maximally discriminative. Cited work demonstrates that website fingerprinting classifiers trained solely on the first few seconds of Tor traffic achieve high accuracy, and real-world GFW detection of fully-encrypted protocols also targets early-connection bytes.

2025-pereira-extended §1 traffic-shapewebsite-fingerprintml-classifierdpifully-encrypted-detect

The framework's GAN-based schedule generator trains on short session windows (e.g., the first 10 seconds) of real browsing traffic from the Tranco Top 1000 sites, learning joint distributions of packet sizes, inter-arrival times, and burst patterns to produce realistic synthetic schedules. This repurposes GAN architectures previously used for traffic analysis (e.g., GANDaLF) as a defense-side cover-traffic generator.

2025-pereira-extended §2.2 traffic-shapewebsite-fingerprintml-classifier

Combinations of Bayesian methods, data augmentation with mixup, and NOTA defensive padding cut the open-world false positive rate by up to 92% at 0.5 recall on HTTPS-only traffic and 75% on Tor traffic relative to the deterministic MSP baseline. Even with these improvements, sustaining a world size in the hundreds of millions (approaching YouTube-scale) requires accepting recall of 0.5–0.6 and precision of only 0.1–0.2; at precision 0.5 and recall 0.5, the maximum workable world size is only 37.5M for HTTPS-only (Table 3), far below YouTube's ~10 billion video catalog.

2025-walsh-improved-open-world-fingerprinting §4.5, Tables 1–3 website-fingerprintml-classifiertraffic-shape