Internet Censorship in China: Where Does the Filtering Occur?

The study located 495 router interfaces with attached IDS filtering devices across China, with CHINANET holding 79.4% and CNCGROUP 17.4%. The two ISPs use fundamentally different placement strategies: CHINANET distributes filtering across provincial networks (80% of its 21 served provinces operate their own filtering devices, Guangdong alone hosting 84 of 374 CHINANET interfaces), while 90% of CNCGROUP's 82 filtering interfaces concentrate in its backbone.

§4.4, Table 2, Table 3 evaluation dpikeyword-filteringrst-injection cn

CNCGROUP's filtering interface count has grown to three times its 2007 level, now accounting for 17.4% of all 495 filtering interfaces found, while CHINANET's count has remained stable since 2007. This divergence indicates CNCGROUP is actively expanding its censorship infrastructure while CHINANET's filtering capacity has matured.

§4.4 evaluation dpikeyword-filtering cn

China's AS-level topology is shallow and concentrated: CHINANET and CNCGROUP together account for 63.9% of 133 unique foreign peerings, 87% of internal ASes are within one hop of a border AS, and just 24 border/backbone ASes serve as effective choke points for all international traffic. The TTL of GFW RST packets is now crafted to prevent IDS localization by TTL inspection, requiring TTL-incrementing probe packets to identify filtering device positions.

§3.2, §3.3, §2 evaluation dpirst-injectionip-blocking cn

The GFW is fully stateful as of 2010: probing all 11,824 Chinese IP prefixes with single TCP packets containing the keyword 'falun' produced no RST responses, confirming that a complete TCP handshake must precede any filtering trigger. Earlier measurements (2006, 2007) reported contradictory results; this study finds statefulness is now universal across all probed prefixes.

§4.1 detection dpirst-injectionkeyword-filtering cn

14 of 495 filtering interfaces (2.9%) are located in non-border internal ASes, all but two belonging to CHINANET provincial subsidiaries. The paper notes that CHINANET's provincial filtering architecture creates infrastructure capable of inspecting inter-provincial domestic traffic, even though there is no current evidence it is being used for that purpose.

§4.4, Table 2 detection dpikeyword-filtering cn