2014-brubaker-cloudtransport
findings extracted from this paper
-
Because CloudTransport uses the same network servers as legitimate cloud services, blocking it requires statistical classification of every cloud connection; false positives will disrupt popular and business-critical cloud applications (enterprise software, games, file backups), raising the economic and social costs of censorship. Empirical evidence shows that Chinese censors declined to block Amazon S3 even after it was used to mirror censored websites because doing so would disrupt 'thousands of services in China' with significant economic consequences. Due to the base-rate fallacy, even an accurate classifier will either miss many CloudTransport connections or cause collateral damage to non-circumventing cloud users.
-
The dead-drop bootstrapping protocol is vulnerable to censor stuffing: because bridge dead drops are publicly advertised and world-writable, censors can flood them with fake tickets containing credentials for non-existing rendezvous accounts, potentially exhausting bridge polling resources. The paper mitigates this only partially via exponential backoff on inactive accounts, and acknowledges that if the censor's stuffing rate significantly exceeds the bridge's check-and-discard rate the attack may hinder bootstrapping. Censors may also delete genuine tickets, though cloud providers such as Dropbox preserve all file versions for 30 days, allowing bridges to collect the first version of every file.
-
CloudTransport achieves 'entanglement' by using the exact same cloud-client libraries, protocols, and network servers as legitimate cloud storage applications, making it immune to protocol-discrepancy detection that defeated imitation systems like SkypeMorph. Iranian censors blocked Tor by exploiting differences in Diffie-Hellman moduli between genuine SSL and Tor's SSL and the expiration dates of Tor's SSL certificates; CloudTransport has no such discrepancies because it is not an imitation. Simple line-speed tests based on tell-tale differences in protocol headers or public keys cannot be used to recognize CloudTransport.
-
CloudTransport's passive-rendezvous design ensures clients never establish direct connections to bridges; consequently, even a censor in complete control of a bridge cannot enumerate client IP addresses without computationally intensive flow-correlation analysis. Blacklisting the IP address of a CloudTransport bridge has zero effect on CloudTransport connections, and when a bridge migrates to a new IP address this change is completely transparent to clients.
-
CloudTransport Cirriform in tunnel and proxified-Tor modes achieves performance comparable to Tor with Obfsproxy across Web browsing (Alexa Top 30 front pages), 300 KB SCP uploads, 10 MB YouTube uploads, and 5-minute 480p streaming video. Bandwidth overhead per message is 350–400 bytes for Amazon S3, with HTTPS adding an extra 2–3% overhead. Per-page browsing costs are as low as $0.00100¢ (Cumuliform on S3), with idle-polling costs of $0.185/day plus $0.34/day/connection for Cirriform on S3.