Autosonda: Discovering Rules and Triggers of Censorship Devices

Of the 55 filters that inspected the HTTP Host header, 26 keyed only on the first Host header in a multi-Host request, 27 keyed only on the last, and only 2 examined both. Placing a benign Host header in the position the filter reads and the blocked URL in the other position bypassed the filter, and this divergence in behavior tracks RFC 7230's requirement to reject multi-Host requests with a 400 error — which none of the tested filters implemented.

§4.1 Mechanism detection dpikeyword-filteringmiddlebox-interference generic

HTTP GET fuzzing via subtle token modifications bypassed large fractions of filters: removing the `\r\n` before the Host header bypassed 36–38 of 44 Host-header filters; embedding the censored URL in the middle of a long hostname string bypassed 33–35 filters; placing the URL in an after-Host field with a non-empty Host bypassed 29–36 filters. Blacklist coverage was also weak: no filter blocked all 100 of the Alexa top adult sites, and some blocked as few as 31.

§4.1 / Appendix A evaluation dpikeyword-filtering generic

Among the 44 non-DNS filters, 11 did not reassemble TCP segments and 7 did not reassemble IP fragments before inspection, meaning a censored URL split across segment or fragment boundaries evaded detection. Five filters applied fragment/segment reassembly timeouts of under 2 seconds despite maintaining HTTP request state for more than 8.5 seconds, creating a window where a deliberately fragmented flow with artificial delay avoids inspection entirely.

§4.1 Mechanism detection dpimiddlebox-interferencekeyword-filtering generic

Autosonda classified 76 commercial web filters in the NYC metropolitan area into three categories: 21 (27.63%) performed DNS blacklist filtering, 44 (57.89%) matched on the HTTP Host header of GET requests, and 11 (14.47%) performed a DNS lookup of the Host header value and blocked based on the resulting IP. Autosonda found circumvention paths for 100% of filters tested.

§4.1 Results evaluation dpidns-poisoningkeyword-filtering generic

All 76 filters inspected only TCP traffic: sending the identical HTTP request over UDP bypassed censorship 100% of the time. Additionally, 17 of the 49 filters that censored requests to EC2 servers only inspected traffic on port 80 and passed through the same requests sent to port 9900 without modification. No filter triggered on URI query strings, so appending query parameters to any censored URL bypassed every tested filter.

§4.1 Mechanism detection dpiport-blockingkeyword-filtering generic