Encrypted Client Hello (ECH) in Censorship Circumvention

Neither China nor Iran directly block ECH ClientHello messages; instead both effectively prevent ECH by censoring encrypted DNS resolvers. China blocks Cloudflare's DoH/DoT resolver (mozilla.cloudflare-dns.com) via SNI-based blocking in TLS and QUIC, causing residual censorship of up to 360 and 180 seconds respectively. Iran blocks both Cloudflare and NextDNS DoH hostnames via DNS block-page injection, TLS TCP RST, and HTTP block pages. Iran cannot analyze QUIC, so DoQ is uncensored and enables ECH in Iran. China's NextDNS IP blackholing affected only one of two resolved IPs, leaving an uncensored path.

§5, Table 1, Figure 5 detection dns-poisoningsni-blockingrst-injectionhttp3-quic-block cnir

Of 640,694 TLS 1.3 servers in the Tranco Top 1M (Feb 2025), 51.28% parse ECH extensions but only 43% actually handshake ECH — and virtually all of those are Cloudflare servers (278,040). Only 6 non-Cloudflare servers successfully handshaked ECH. Cloudflare's own servers have a 44% non-advertisement rate: servers that can handshake ECH but do not publish their ECH configuration in DNS, typically because the operator manages their own DNS outside Cloudflare. The total number of advertised ECH configurations dropped from ~180,000 in November 2024 to ~150,000 by April 2025.

§4.1, §4.2, Figure 3, Figure 4 evaluation sni-blockingesni-eh-blocking generic

Chrome and Firefox send GREASE ECH extensions in every ClientHello message, meaning a censor that blocks all ECH-containing ClientHellos would block all Chrome and Firefox TLS traffic. Cloudflare's static outer SNI "cloudflare-ech.com" in all its ECH configurations makes real ECH connections trivially distinguishable from GREASE ECH — censors can block real ECH connections to Cloudflare without triggering GREASE collateral damage. Cloudflare rejects ECH handshakes with omitted or invalidated outer SNI values; non-Cloudflare ECH deployments accept missing and invalid outer SNIs.

§2.1, §4.1, §6 detection sni-blockingesni-eh-blocking cnirru

Russian TSPU devices directly block ECH by dropping ClientHello messages that contain both an ECH extension and the outer SNI hostname "cloudflare-ech.com" — the static outer SNI Cloudflare advertises in all its ECH configurations. Blocking affects both TLS and QUIC. ECH connections to servers with Cloudflare ECH support but outside Cloudflare's official IP ranges are NOT blocked. TCP segmentation alone or TLS record fragmentation alone did NOT bypass TSPU ECH blocking, but combining both techniques did circumvent it. TSPU has also added TCP reassembly capabilities that defeat previously effective fragmentation-only bypasses.

§5, Figure 5 detection dpirst-injectionmiddlebox-interference ru