Known Unknowns: An Analysis of Twitter Censorship in Turkey

Among withheld retweets in the Turkish dataset, 92% of the corresponding original tweets were also withheld, while 4% survived uncensored and 4% belonged to fully-withheld accounts; this asymmetry suggests the Turkish government's censorship targeting mechanism operates with some degree of systematic (possibly hashtag- or keyword-based) sweep rather than purely manual per-tweet review.

§5.2 (Phase III) detection keyword-filtering tr

Manual review of 46 fully-withheld Turkish accounts found that 36 (78%) were classified as posting anti-government political content critical of President Erdoğan, 2 as pornography, 1 as advertising bots, 3 as unidentified, and 4 as no-longer-findable; NMF/tf-idf topic modeling of withheld individual tweets confirmed that the dominant censored themes were criticism of government-aligned media and ruling-party politicians.

§6.1, §6.2 evaluation keyword-filtering tr

Twitter's country-withheld content mechanism relies on a browser-set location cookie, not IP geolocation; the authors confirmed that viewing a known-withheld Turkish tweet via a Turkish proxy server did not trigger the withholding display, but manually changing the Twitter app's location setting to 'Turkey' did — meaning any Turkish user who sets their location to a different country can bypass the entire withholding mechanism without Tor or a VPN.

§7 defense ip-blocking tr

The Chilling Effects database contained only 33 notices from Twitter across all countries, far fewer than the 108 account-withholding requests disclosed in Twitter's own transparency reports for the same period; Twitter itself acknowledges its transparency reporting is neither 100% comprehensive nor complete, and the authors confirmed that at least 86% of Turkish government withholding requests for non-protected tweets were approved by Twitter.

§3.1, §4.2 policy keyword-filtering tr

Twitter's official transparency reports for Turkey recorded 183 withheld tweets (Jan–Jun 2014) and 1,820 withheld tweets (Jul–Dec 2014), but the authors' collection of 17 million geo-bounded Turkish tweets yielded 3,258 withheld tweets from the streaming phase alone, and expanding to followers of censored accounts produced 171,652 withheld tweets—roughly two orders of magnitude more than Twitter's own disclosures.

§4.1, §5.2 evaluation keyword-filtering tr